Alexa Curtis, 19, laid her laptop on her dinner table and took a deep breath.
It was a brisk April evening, and Curtis was prepared to spend the night in her Boston apartment watching the new Netflix series “13 Reasons Why.”
As the first three episodes of the teen drama unfolded on her computer screen, Curtis’ heart began to race.
“13 Reasons Why” is based on best-selling author Jay Asher’s 2007 young adult book of the same title. Actress and pop star Selena Gomez co-produced the 13-episode Netflix adaptation.
The series, which premiered March 31, follows the fictional story of a teenage girl named Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford) who leaves behind 13 mysterious audio recordings on cassette tapes after killing herself. She addresses each recording to a person who she says played a role in her tragic decision to end her own life.
“The first thing that popped into my mind when watching it was, ‘Wow,’ ” said Curtis, who founded the nonprofit Media Impact and Navigation for Teens, a program that raises awareness about online bullying.
Curtis said she was bullied in high school and she could have been a real-life Hannah Baker.
“Had I been watching that as the vulnerable, fragile kid that I was when I was 13 or 14, I might have watched that and thought, ‘Oh, that’s the easy way out. This is going to get me the attention that I need. This is what I have to do,’ ” said Curtis, who wrote an opinion article in Rolling Stone this month about the series.
“It’s not the kind of show that I would say nobody should watch, but I think that every school right now should have an open conversation about it in health class,” she said. “Kids should probably even be separately brought aside, as privately as possible, and spoken to about it. Any kids who are known to have depression, to have spoken to counselors or any previous suicide attempts, I think they should be very, very, very talked to in-depth about it.”
Some mental health experts say the show could pose health risks for certain young people, such as those who have suicidal thoughts.
Others suggest the show provides a valuable opportunity to discuss suicide risk with young people, as well as teaching them how to identify warning signs of depression or suicidal thoughts among their peers.
Among American young people, those between ages 10 and 24, suicide is the third leading cause of death, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Each year, about 157,000 people in that age range receive medical care for self-inflicted injuries at emergency departments across the United States, according to the CDC.
Suicide rates among this age group have also been rising in the UK in recent years, according to UK charity Samaritans, reaching more than 15 per 100,000 people aged 10-24 in 2015. In Australia rates were an estimated 50 per 100,000 for the same age group in 2015, according to the Australian government’s mental health awareness initiative, Mindframe.
Ohio school district sends parents letter of concern
In light of the popularity of the show among young people, a central Ohio school district sent letters to parents expressing concern about the series.
Middle school counselors from the New Albany-Plain Local School District are calling on parents to discuss the show and teenage suicide with their children.
According to ABC-6, the counselors said the show oversimplifies suicide, doesn’t address mental illness and disputes the main theme of peer kindness being enough to solve the problem.
Some parents told ABC-6 that they’re watching the show with their kids and it’s prompted open conversations about suicide.
“Dear Middle School Families,
As your child’s school counselor, it is our job to focus on the social, emotional and academic needs of all students. This is why we felt it was important to reach out to all New Albany Middle School families and make them aware of a new television series that is a bit concerning to us.
13 Reasons Why is a new series on Netflix and is already claimed to be the most watched series that Netflix has ever produced. If you have not watched or heard about this series, it follows a high schooler who has received 13 cassette tapes made by a classmate before she died by suicide; the tapes explain her 13 reasons for killing herself, essentially uncovering dark secrets that caused her suicide.
Here are a few of the concerns surrounding the series:
- This show is FICTION, though many people (children and adults alike) are taking the show as the reality for many high school students today.
- The graphic depictions of bullying, sexual harassment, sexual assault, rape, and suicide can be very triggering, especially for anyone who is or has struggled with any of these things.
- Young people may over identify with the characters in this show, particularly the main protagonist, Hannah, who dies by suicide.
- The show very much over-simplifies suicide. The majority of people who have suicidal thoughts, suicide attempts, or die by suicide, have an underlying mental illness that they need professional treatment for. This show does not mention mental illness, or specifically, depression, at all. Not even once.
- The 13 tapes created by Hannah before her death romanticize the ability to speak to people “from the beyond.” This is completely unrealistic. The tapes would have taken a rational mind to create; Hannah was not thinking rationally near the end of her life. In fact, most people who die by suicide end up acting impulsively at the very end. Suicide notes are not common.
- The other theme throughout the show seems to be about how kindness can save lives. Sounds great, right? After all, we want our children to be kind. However, Hannah references in almost all of her tapes that if that person had just done one thing differently, she might not feel as badly as she does. In the last episode, Hannah says, “Some of you cared. None of you cared enough.” Kindness is not enough; suicidal ideation requires PROFESSIONAL help! Again, this is not mentioned AT ALL in this series. Let’s not let the message to our children be that if they had just been more kind to so-and-so, maybe they wouldn’t have killed themselves. Talk about guilt!
- The adults in this series, yikes. None of them appear to know how to help when they see their children/students struggling, or they don’t have the time. This is also a very dangerous message. The School Counselor in the series, Mr. Porter, is cringe-worthy when it comes to his responses to Hannah in the last episode. He is dismissive, distracted, and unhelpful. We need our children to know that there ARE adults who will listen and who know how to help them.
- There are little to no help-seeking behaviors shown in this series. Hannah appears to be helpless and hopeless. The series offers no alternatives to suicide as a means to deal with serious problems.
- Contagion. Experts in this field know that research shows that young people are more likely to attempt or die by suicide themselves after experiencing a suicide death of someone close to them (about 4 to 5 times more likely). You might say, “But this is just a show. They don’t really know Hannah.” And you would be right, except that there has already been an increase in young people who are attempting suicide in the same way depicted in the show. Contagion is real.
- Finally, producers of this show claim to have consulted suicide experts and medial portrayal experts. The truth is that they did not consult said experts until after the show was already completed.
Why are we sharing this information and sending this email? We have received a few parent phone calls and emails surrounding this series and we feel, as a school, that there is a possibility that this program could affect the emotional safety of our students.
What are the next steps? We would like the opportunity to have a parent information meeting regarding the curriculum that we utilize with our middle and high schoolers for depression, anxiety, suicide prevention and self-harm. If you would be interested in attending this, please click on this link and fill out the google form. We will hold a parent information meeting before the end of the school year.
Please know that when we take this topic very seriously and that every student’s well-being is our number one priority. When we discuss any mental health concern with students, our emphasis is for them to identify and tell a responsible adult. Our fear is that this series could be giving our children mixed messages about the appropriate ways to help a friend.”
‘Dispel the myth’
“Suicide contagion” describes when exposure to suicide within a family, within a group of friends or through the media may be associated with an increase in suicidal behaviors, according to the US Department of Health and Human Services.
Among 12- to 13-year-olds, being exposed to a classmate’s suicide was associated with being five times more likely to have suicidal thoughts, according to a study published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal (PDF) in 2013.
The risk of suicide contagion and copycat behavior is one of mental health experts’ leading causes of concern tied to “13 Reasons Why.”
“Research shows that exposure to another person’s suicide, or to graphic or sensationalized accounts of death, can be one of the many risk factors that youth struggling with mental health conditions cite as a reason they contemplate or attempt suicide,” according to a statement about the show released this month by the National Association of School Psychologists.
However, it’s unlikely that one show alone could trigger someone to attempt suicide, said Eric Beeson, a licensed professional counselor who serves as an online faculty member at The Family Institute at Northwestern University.
“Research clearly shows that these images have an influence on suicidal behaviors, but how this occurs is far more important to me,” he said. “It is very possible that provocative experiences have a desensitizing effect that makes suicidal behaviors more likely.”
One of the writers of the “13 Reasons Why” series has defended the decision not to shy away from main character Hannah’s suicide and to include a graphic scene of her death.
In an op-ed published in Vanity Fair last week, writer Nic Sheff revealed that he had once tried to take his own life. He brought that experience to his work on episode 6 of the show.
“From the very beginning, I agreed that we should depict the suicide with as much detail and accuracy as possible. I even argued for it — relating the story of my own suicide attempt to the other writers,” he wrote.
In the op-ed, Sheff detailed how a woman once told him about her own suicide attempt: After she washed down a copious amount of pills with wine, what followed were moments of excruciating pain, of violently vomiting blood and blacking out. Then she dialed 911. The thought of her experience caused Sheff to put down some pills he was swallowing in his own suicide attempt, he wrote.
“If that woman had not told me her story, I wouldn’t be here now. I would’ve missed out on all the amazing gifts I have in my life today,” Sheff wrote.
“So when it came time to discuss the portrayal of the protagonist’s suicide in ’13 Reasons Why,’ I of course immediately flashed on my own experience. It seemed to me the perfect opportunity to show what an actual suicide really looks like — to dispel the myth of the quiet drifting off,” he wrote. “It overwhelmingly seems to me that the most irresponsible thing we could’ve done would have been not to show the death at all.”
CNN contacted Netflix for comment but has not heard back from a representative affiliated with “13 Reasons Why.”
Cautions and guidance for parents, educators
School districts across the country — including the Shawnee Mission School District in Kansas and Montclair Public Schools in New Jersey — are sending letters to parents about the suicide-related content on the show.
“I heard about the series from young people I see in my private practice and from other students,” said Andrew Evangelista, mental health and harassment, intimidation and bullying coordinator at Montclair Public Schools.
Evangelista, who has been a therapist for more than 40 years, said he originally sent a letter about the show to school principals and administrators in the district. They encouraged him to share it with parents.
“I felt it was a great opportunity for staff, counselors and parents to connect with their children by using it as a teachable moment,” Evangelista said. “The girl Hannah, even though she is fictional, teens — if vulnerable and at risk — may identity with her.”
Evangelista said parents can watch for warning signs their child may be vulnerable to identifying with Hannah’s character. They include the child spending more alone time in their room, being secretive with their phone or computer, or having a history of nonsuicidal self-injury such as cutting, he said.
The counseling department at Shawnee Mission South High School in Kansas also offered some tips in a letter posted publicly to the school’s PTSA Facebook page.
“Check it out yourself, do some reading, watch an episode to be aware of the issues in the show. If your teenager is watching it, take the time to have conversations about the content, possibly watching together,” the letter said. “Experts feel that the series may be romanticizing suicide and not encouraging teenagers to seek help from family or counselors.”
The statement from the National Association of School Psychologists includes “cautions” and “guidance” for educators and families of teens who might watch the show.
“We do not recommend that vulnerable youth, especially those who have any degree of suicidal ideation, watch this series. Its powerful storytelling may lead impressionable viewers to romanticize the choices made by the characters and/or develop revenge fantasies,” the statement said. “While many youth are resilient and capable of differentiating between a TV drama and real life, engaging in thoughtful conversations with them about the show is vital.”
Curtis, the founder of Media Impact and Navigation for Teens, said she was thrilled to see the association release that statement.
However, “I almost wish that they hadn’t used the word ‘vulnerable,’ because I almost think that every young adult is vulnerable, whether they are being bullied or whether they are the bully,” she said.
Beeson, the licensed professional counselor, said he thinks the statement was balanced.
“I can’t say that there is a group of people that ‘shouldn’t’ watch this show. I think it is more important how people watch it, with whom, and how it is processed afterward,” Beeson said. He added that there are elements of the show that he was pleased with and some he was left second-guessing.
“I appreciated the depiction of suicide as a process. There is no singular cause for suicide, and the show depicted the cumulative effect of multiple life experiences leading up to Hannah’s suicide. Even though I don’t like that the show sometimes vilified the people in the tapes as the ‘reasons’ why Hannah killed herself,” Beeson said.
“One narrative that has been lost in the controversy about this show is the belief by some of the characters that things had to get better, they had to care and treat one another better,” he said.
“To me, this show goes far beyond the suicide narrative and evokes a broader conversation about the power of human interaction and connection. I hope that all who watch this show walk away with an appreciation for the importance of every interaction we have, however insignificant it might seem, and the importance to reach out, show interest and care for those around us.”
Curtis has similar hopes.
‘Those are the Hannah Bakers’
As Curtis reflects on the bullying she endured in high school and the suicidal thoughts she once had, she often thinks about her 14th birthday.
To celebrate the day, a poster with her name on it was hung in a hallway of her high school in Storrs, Connecticut — a tradition that was practiced with all the students on their birthdays.
“A few girls just destroyed mine,” Curtis said.
“They put terrible words on it, like calling me a slut and the c-word and a b*tch, all of these things,” she said. “The principal ended up getting involved, and my mom got involved, and it was just terrible. … Situations like that, they really stick with you for the rest of your life”
Now, Curtis hopes that “13 Reasons Why” will encourage young people to speak out about personal struggles and not view suicide as “a way out.”
“The biggest advice I could give to somebody is to start talking. Whether it’s talking to a friend, whether it’s talking to a parent, having one person, you only need one person in your life who you can just rely on,” she said. “It’s the kids who don’t have that one person, that’s the group we need to figure out how to hit and how to talk to. Because those are the Hannah Bakers.”